Benefits claim man who said he was too ill to work caught playing golf - court
Last updated at 12:16, Tuesday, 06 March 2012
A Cumbrian man who claimed nearly £39,000 in Disability Living Allowance over nine years was secretly filmed playing golf and renovating a house, a court heard.
On his claim form, filled out in 2001, Leigh Neilly, 41, told officials he could walk no more than 100m without feeling severe discomfort and that it took him up to 10 minutes to cover that distance.
He said he needed somebody beside him outside because there was a danger his legs might “give way”.
Neilly also wrote that he had difficulty gripping a toothbrush, the jury heard.
But Carlisle Crown Court was yesterday shown a series of covert surveillance videos taken last year. On one occasion, said prosecutor Tim Evans, the defendant was filmed striding across Silloth Golf Course and he was filmed driving the ball down the fairway.
Neilly denies benefit fraud by making false claims about his health, and a charge of failing to tell the Department for Work and Pensions (DWP) his health had improved enough to affect his claim.
Mr Evans said benefit fraud is not a victimless crime because taxpayers are defrauded when money goes to those who do not deserve it.
“The Crown says that Leigh Neilly is just such an individual: that he made a claim to benefit suggesting he had a severe disability which he quite simply did not have,” said Mr Evans.
Mr Evans said that the Crown’s case was that Neilly’s claim for Disability Living Allowance (DLA) – made in October 2001 – had been fraudulent from the outset. He said: “In any event, it is plain he was not throughout the period you are concerned with severely disabled. You will see his prowess on the golf course and his house renovations.
“It is plain, therefore, that if it ever was severe – which the Crown suggest it was never – that it came to very significantly improve.”
The jury was then shown a series of video surveillance clips, taken at various times during 2010, when Neilly, of Wampool Street, Silloth, was still claiming DLA.
In the video of Mr Neilly on Silloth Golf Course, said Mr Evans, he is seen striding across the green, with nobody there to support him.
Commenting of a shot which the prosecutions says shows the defendant driving the ball across the fairway, Mr Evans said: “You can see what happens – the ball goes, and the club stays.” In another clip, Neilly is shown chipping the ball onto the green.
Mr Evans said the jury should ask whether this was a man who had trouble gripping a toothbrush?
Between April 2001 and July 2002, a period straddling the defendant’s DLA claim, Neilly played 19 rounds of competitive golf, the jury heard.Between 2002, when he joined Silloth Golf Club, and 2008, his golfing handicap improved, said Mr Evans.At no point in his eight years as a member of the club, continued the barrister, did Neilly use the motorised golf buggy available for members who had trouble walking.
The jury then heard evidence from DWP fraud investigator Alan Robinson, who led the covert surveillance of the defendant in 2010.
Mr Robinson confirmed that a man seen arriving on a bike at a house in Silloth and then working on its renovation was the defendant.
The film showed him carrying a ladder, and shaking out a dust sheet, and also emptying a large bucket of water onto the street. Later footage showed the same man cycling home, with just one hand on the handlebars because he was smoking a cigarette.
In yet another video sequence, the defendant was filmed walking through Penrith town centre, and browsing in the town’s British Heart Foundation charity shop.
The final sequence shows Neilly carrying two large shopping bags back to his Motability car with his wife walking at his side. Asked how far the defendant had walked that day, Mr Robinson confirmed that he had measured the distance as being 1,489 yards.
“At any stage,” asked Mr Evans, “did he have to stop and rest?” Mr Robinson replied: “I did not see that at all.”
The case continues.
First published at 11:29, Tuesday, 06 March 2012
Published by http://www.newsandstar.co.uk
More Dalton news
- MP backs call to save South Cumbria pub (9 comments)
- Dalton St Mary’s Christingle (1 comment)
- Dalton NatWest branch set to close (5 comments)
- Dalton chefs event set to serve up charity aid
- Hundreds celebrate Dalton Christmas lights switch on
- Cold war nuclear crash may have caused Dalton man’s cancer (1 comment)
- Dalton Zoo boss guilty of allowing birds to escape
- ‘Family spat’ probably led to Dalton monkey escape (1 comment)
- Dalton is named one of the best places for families
- Smurfs spotted out and about on Dalton school’s sponsored stroll
- Kind £1,000 donation will help Dalton girl to watch the world go by
- Shoplifter caught in Dalton with £500 admitted money laundering
- Legal error results in Dalton zoo chief facing wrong charges (1 comment)
- Man shattered window in Dalton after row with his ex
- Dalton family’s distress after raiders stole ‘irreplaceable’ jewellery
- Tributes to 'witty and lovely' Dalton man who died a month after transplant (1 comment)
- Cumbria Police investigate burglary in Dalton
- Dalton schoolgirl suffers broken foot following collision with vehicle
- Dalton hotel set to reopen after gas canister explosion in kitchen (2 comments)
- Naked men seen walking through Dalton (15 comments)
- Dalton zoo is handed series of new conditions after inspection
- Council hits back in Dalton zoo tiger feeding row (45 comments)
- Dalton fire station sold to highest bidder for £130,000 (1 comment)
- Dalton Leisure centre full steam ahead after grant for boilers
- Dalton man pleads not guilty to dangerous driving